800 Ford retirees formally object to deal that requires paying health premiums, deductibles
by : Bryce G. Hoffman
Sunday June 4, 2006 - 23:37
Ford, UAW retirees spar in court over health insurance cuts
by Bryce G. Hoffman
DETROIT — Dozens of Ford Motor Co. union retirees were in federal court Wednesday to ask a judge to reject an agreement between the automaker and the United Auto Workers that would cut their health benefits to help ease Ford’s financial troubles.
The retirees argued that they were denied a say in the deal, which could cost them hundreds of dollars a year in higher health care costs.
Larry Bronson, a former vice president of UAW Local 600 in Dearborn, described the long fight for retiree health benefits he waged with other union activists and said he never imagined he would lose them in retirement.
"It was written in stone basically, like the Ten Commandments," said Bronson, who accused UAW leaders who negotiated the Ford deal of sacrificing retirees for the sake of their careers. "They’re not acting on my behalf," he said. "They’re acting to perpetuate themselves in office."
Attorneys for the UAW said the union acted appropriately. Ford’s lawyers urged U.S. District Judge Paul Borman to approve the deal by July. They called the automaker’s financial situation "dire" and said the company needs the health care agreement to shave costs. Ford is in the midst of a restructuring that will cut 30,000 jobs and close 14 plants by 2012.
"Ford, your honor, needs this settlement approved with all deliberate speed," said Ford attorney Jonathan Abram. He called the plan "fair and generous" and added that Wall Street is counting on the deal being approved.
Bronson was the lead plaintiff in a lawsuit that sought to block the health care agreement. That case was not allowed to go forward. But attorney Mark Baumkel, who represented Bronson and other plaintiffs, was in court Wednesday to plead their case. "The UAW negotiated this deal without the power to do so," Baumkel said, arguing that the union has no authority to negotiate on behalf of retirees. "The union can’t give away their rights without getting their consent — and that didn’t happen here."
There were also dozens of retirees in court to support the deal, most bussed in by the union. Some said they were afraid Ford’s mounting financial woes could lead the company to bankruptcy and leave them without any retirement benefits.
Borman instructed attorneys on both sides to submit supporting documents by June 12 and said he would rule on the case after that date.
Under the terms of Ford’s agreement with the union, which was narrowly approved by active UAW members in December, retirees will be required to pay monthly health insurance premiums and deductibles that could total up to $370 a year for individuals and $752 for a family. That figure can go up by as much as 3 percent annually. In addition, some workers would pay more for prescription drugs.
Hourly retirees at Ford are not required to pay any fees for health care coverage now. Most retirees or their surviving dependents who receive pensions of less than $8,000 will not have to pay the new fees either.
Ford spent $3.5 billion last year to provide health care to 590,000 people, including employees, retirees and dependants. Its health care costs have soared 67 percent since 2000 and the company now spends $1,100 per vehicle on health care — more than what it spends on steel. Ford’s health care obligation to retirees totals $35 billion.
If approved, the deal with the UAW would reduce that obligation by $5 billion, Abram said. It will also improve pretax profits by $650 million and bolster the company’s cash position by $200 million annually.
Abram reminded the judge that one of his colleagues had approved a similar deal between the UAW and General Motors Corp. earlier this year. Without similar relief, he said Ford is at a competitive disadvantage.
The deal requires court approval because the UAW cannot negotiate on behalf of retirees. Some 800 of about 150,000 Ford retirees have filed formal objections to the deal. Some — from as far away as Oregon — made the trip to the federal courthouse in Detroit to voice their objections in person.
"I don’t think it was fair for them to vote on my cuts," said James Lynch, who retired in 1997 from the Rouge River complex. "What good does it do to retire with benefits if they can turn around and take them away from you?"
YES, THERE WILL BE ELECTION FRAUD, AND ON A GRAND SCALE
Sunday 23 - 18:32by JOHN CHUCKMAN
Hillary Clinton will be first female President 2017
Monday 10 - 17:21by Willam Morgan
Police Shootings: Law, Policy, and Accountability
Thursday 6 - 14:22by William John Cox
AMERICA DESERVES BETTER, BUT EVEN MORE IMPORTANTLY, THE WORLD DESERVES BETTER
Thursday 29 - 18:02by JOHN CHUCKMAN
Back to School for Fascist Dupont-Aignan
Thursday 15 - 11:32by Nouveau Comité de Vigilance des Intellectuels Antifascistes
The Presidency: Character Matters
Friday 9 - 15:06by William John Cox
WHY HILLARY IS THE PERFECT PERSON TO SECURE OBAMA’S LEGACY
Tuesday 30 - 18:08by JOHN CHUCKMAN
Remake of Ben Hur in 2020 planned by new motion picture studio
Friday 26 - 15:50by Wallace
THE CASE FOR DONALD TRUMP
Monday 22 - 19:32by JOHN CHUCKMAN
THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES IS DEAD
Thursday 11 - 06:42by David R. Hoffman, Legal Editor of Pravda.Ru
DONALD TRUMP AND THE GENIUS OF IDIOCY
Friday 5 - 00:47by David R. Hoffman, Legal Editor of Pravda.Ru
FOOLING MOST OF THE PEOPLE MOST OF THE TIME IS WHAT AMERICAN POLITICS ARE ABOUT,
Friday 29 - 18:13by JOHN CHUCKMAN
A message of your fellow striking workers from France
Tuesday 12 - 20:49by Info’Com-CGT
The Right to Vote, Effectively
Friday 8 - 22:20by William John Cox
Fourth of July Lies
Sunday 3 - 19:41by June C. Terpstra
Who Should Make Political Policy, the People or the Politicians?
Friday 24 - 15:14by William John Cox
Hollow Women of the Hegemon Part II: Atrocity Enabling Harpies
Tuesday 21 - 18:49by Dr. June Terpstra
The American Republic Manifestum book is being made into a Movie
Saturday 11 - 15:54by William Morgan
Write-in Voting and Political Protest
Wednesday 1 - 15:05by William John Cox
Yves Bouvier art battle plays out in online and social media arena
Tuesday 31 - 21:12by Dean Bagley
Damaged Candidate Clinton Can’t Call Out Trump
Friday 27 - 13:53by Daniel Patrick Welch
PLEDGE OF THE NEW REPUBLICAN PARTY
Tuesday 24 - 21:53by David R. Hoffman, Legal Editor of Pravda.Ru
LET TEXAS SECEDE
Thursday 19 - 00:53by David R. Hoffman, Legal Editor of Pravda.Ru
LAS TRES ERRES A LA ENÉSIMA POTENCIA.-
Monday 16 - 15:35by FREDDY SUBDIAGA
Monday 16 - 15:26by FREDDY SUBDIAGA
Oligarchs Won’t Let You Vote Their Wars Away
Wednesday 11 - 20:24by Daniel Patrick Welch
AN AMERICAN ORIGINAL: JOHN KERRY - FROM HIS REMARKABLE RECENT COMMENCEMENT ADDR
Monday 9 - 20:40by JOHN CHUCKMAN
Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton support the American Republic Manifestum
Monday 9 - 16:37by William Morgan
Transformation: A Student-Led Mass Political Movement
Monday 25 - 19:28by William John Cox
Algerian Feminists react to ’Hijab Day’ in Paris 2016
Monday 25 - 01:13
THE ILLUSION OF RIGHTS
Friday 22 - 18:45by JOHN CHUCKMAN
US is real superpredator pretending to be victim
Monday 18 - 22:23by Daniel Patrick Welch
Gaiacomm International has accidently created a fusion reaction/ignition.
Sunday 17 - 17:01by William Morgan
Clinton’s Campaign Continues to Highlight Horrible Hillary
Saturday 9 - 00:57by Daniel Patrick Welch
Armoiries racistes à Harvard : Plaidoyer pour la réflexion socio-historique
Thursday 7 - 18:56by Samuel Beaudoin Guzzo
THANK YOU MISSISSIPPI FOR YOUR HATE
Wednesday 6 - 02:02by David R. Hoffman, Legal Editor of Pravda.Ru
The PKK in Iraq: “We are ready to fight ISIS everywhere in the world”
Monday 4 - 14:33by InfoAut
Clinton Crashes and Burns, Sanders Will Win (But hold off on the applause)
Friday 1 - 22:33by Daniel Patrick Welch
Confirming Supreme Court Justices and Electing Presidents
Friday 1 - 20:59by William John Cox
PCBS: "As Palestinians Mark Land Day, Israeli Illegally Controls More Than 85% O
Wednesday 30 - 14:06by Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics - PCBS