800 Ford retirees formally object to deal that requires paying health premiums, deductibles
by : Bryce G. Hoffman
Sunday June 4, 2006 - 23:37
Ford, UAW retirees spar in court over health insurance cuts
by Bryce G. Hoffman
DETROIT — Dozens of Ford Motor Co. union retirees were in federal court Wednesday to ask a judge to reject an agreement between the automaker and the United Auto Workers that would cut their health benefits to help ease Ford’s financial troubles.
The retirees argued that they were denied a say in the deal, which could cost them hundreds of dollars a year in higher health care costs.
Larry Bronson, a former vice president of UAW Local 600 in Dearborn, described the long fight for retiree health benefits he waged with other union activists and said he never imagined he would lose them in retirement.
"It was written in stone basically, like the Ten Commandments," said Bronson, who accused UAW leaders who negotiated the Ford deal of sacrificing retirees for the sake of their careers. "They’re not acting on my behalf," he said. "They’re acting to perpetuate themselves in office."
Attorneys for the UAW said the union acted appropriately. Ford’s lawyers urged U.S. District Judge Paul Borman to approve the deal by July. They called the automaker’s financial situation "dire" and said the company needs the health care agreement to shave costs. Ford is in the midst of a restructuring that will cut 30,000 jobs and close 14 plants by 2012.
"Ford, your honor, needs this settlement approved with all deliberate speed," said Ford attorney Jonathan Abram. He called the plan "fair and generous" and added that Wall Street is counting on the deal being approved.
Bronson was the lead plaintiff in a lawsuit that sought to block the health care agreement. That case was not allowed to go forward. But attorney Mark Baumkel, who represented Bronson and other plaintiffs, was in court Wednesday to plead their case. "The UAW negotiated this deal without the power to do so," Baumkel said, arguing that the union has no authority to negotiate on behalf of retirees. "The union can’t give away their rights without getting their consent — and that didn’t happen here."
There were also dozens of retirees in court to support the deal, most bussed in by the union. Some said they were afraid Ford’s mounting financial woes could lead the company to bankruptcy and leave them without any retirement benefits.
Borman instructed attorneys on both sides to submit supporting documents by June 12 and said he would rule on the case after that date.
Under the terms of Ford’s agreement with the union, which was narrowly approved by active UAW members in December, retirees will be required to pay monthly health insurance premiums and deductibles that could total up to $370 a year for individuals and $752 for a family. That figure can go up by as much as 3 percent annually. In addition, some workers would pay more for prescription drugs.
Hourly retirees at Ford are not required to pay any fees for health care coverage now. Most retirees or their surviving dependents who receive pensions of less than $8,000 will not have to pay the new fees either.
Ford spent $3.5 billion last year to provide health care to 590,000 people, including employees, retirees and dependants. Its health care costs have soared 67 percent since 2000 and the company now spends $1,100 per vehicle on health care — more than what it spends on steel. Ford’s health care obligation to retirees totals $35 billion.
If approved, the deal with the UAW would reduce that obligation by $5 billion, Abram said. It will also improve pretax profits by $650 million and bolster the company’s cash position by $200 million annually.
Abram reminded the judge that one of his colleagues had approved a similar deal between the UAW and General Motors Corp. earlier this year. Without similar relief, he said Ford is at a competitive disadvantage.
The deal requires court approval because the UAW cannot negotiate on behalf of retirees. Some 800 of about 150,000 Ford retirees have filed formal objections to the deal. Some — from as far away as Oregon — made the trip to the federal courthouse in Detroit to voice their objections in person.
"I don’t think it was fair for them to vote on my cuts," said James Lynch, who retired in 1997 from the Rouge River complex. "What good does it do to retire with benefits if they can turn around and take them away from you?"
Paris: One step beyond in the systemic chaos
Monday 23 - 11:11by InfoAut
FRIDAY THE THIRTEENTH IN PARIS AND THE UGLY TRUTH OF STATE TERROR
Thursday 19 - 20:08by JOHN CHUCKMAN
AFTER THE ATTACKS
Tuesday 17 - 23:07by CAPJPO-EuroPalestine
Terrorism victims file $3.4bn lawsuit against Bnp Paribas, violating sanctions
Sunday 15 - 00:18by Kevin Dugan
Slavery, corruption... Larsen & Toubro and Qatar have so much in common
Thursday 12 - 17:16by Robert Scott
Advisers Lock Horns in Yves Bouvier Art Fraud Battle
Thursday 15 - 18:04by GraemeListing72
Smashing the Abbas icon of Palestinian non – violence
Wednesday 14 - 11:42by Nicola Nasser
More Scud than BUK: Despite Fiery Rhetoric, West Beats Strategic Retreat on MH17
Tuesday 13 - 22:28by Daniel Patrick Welch
The Pornography of Hatred
Friday 9 - 19:45by William John Cox
You Mad, Bro? US resopnse to Russia’s Syria action is off the charts
Wednesday 7 - 20:07by Daniel Patrick Welch
Pope’s address to Bishops raises larger questions, contradictions in visit to US
Friday 25 - 14:04by Daniel Patrick Welch
Culture as merchandise, thanks to recent copyright reform
Monday 21 - 11:18by Isabel Adams
BIG DEMO IN PARIS ON SATURDAY FOR THE RIGHT OF RETURN FOR PALESTINIAN REFUGEES
Wednesday 16 - 18:45by CAPJPO-EuroPalestine
What Young Angolans Can Learn from Mirco Martins
Tuesday 15 - 23:52
Imperial arrogance spews from US mouthpieces—"warning" Russia on Ukraine, Syria
Tuesday 15 - 21:06by Daniel Patrick Welch
Wars of Opportunity: West and its gulf allies just won’t stop
Saturday 12 - 20:46by Daniel Patrick Welch
US claims Russia ’destabilizing Syria’ stand the truth on its head
Wednesday 9 - 23:46by Daniel Patrick Welch
AMERICA’S "JUSTICE" SYSTEM IS A LIE
Saturday 29 - 03:41by David R. Hoffman, Legal Editor of Pravda.Ru
Mirco Martins helping Angola children with education foundation
Monday 24 - 23:13
Armed demonstrators protest Sandra Bland arrest, death
Friday 14 - 17:04by seattletimes
San Quintín Valley: From labor abuse to labor mobilization
Thursday 13 - 02:34by Guillermo Castillo
THE COUNTER-REFORM OF MICHOACÁN’S INDIGENOUS UNIVERSITY (1)
Wednesday 12 - 22:07
Rumored Sale of Banque Pasche to Banque Havilland
Monday 10 - 17:17by Bolton Rease
Unwelcome Truths for Church and State
Sunday 9 - 12:36by Gary G. Kohls, MD
Jose Gama questioning an unsurprising development
Friday 7 - 00:09by Cesar Amiente
Rests behind your border Erdogan !…
Tuesday 4 - 11:27by laurentgantner
Let’s raise our european OXI !
Monday 3 - 21:40by Blockupy International
UPDATE: Get somebody with a history, not an opportunist
Wednesday 29 - 06:38by Timbre Wolf
Between the democracy and the war, there is Recep Tayyip Erdogan…
Tuesday 28 - 20:58by laurentgantner
Luanda Poised to Take Its Place on the World Stage
Monday 27 - 22:51
Saturday 25 - 00:05by Timbre Wolf
Grexit, first Act
Friday 24 - 13:09by Raffaele Sciortino
Europe’s Impossible Dream
Tuesday 21 - 16:58by Paul Krugman
"The Streets Of Athens Will Fill With Tanks"
Tuesday 21 - 16:44by Tyler Durden
Who is Flavio Becca? The bricklayer who is about to crash
Monday 20 - 15:04
SCOTT WALKER: SATAN’S CANDIDATE
Sunday 19 - 02:21by David R. Hoffman, Legal Editor of Pravda.Ru
Greece, austerity and the questions to pose
Friday 17 - 22:34by InfoAut
Tomorrow (on Saturday) it will stay 48 hours in Alexeï Tsipras To create the BMG
Friday 17 - 17:03by laurentgantner
Meet Leonid Sedov, the young lawyer behind Ukraine’s corruption
Thursday 16 - 19:27by Oleg Karpov
Maka Angola and Rafael Marques should have nothing to hide from Angola’s NGO ref
Saturday 11 - 17:22by Celia Perron